Call Us Now
Email Us NowSarasota Drunk Driving Accident Attorney
Someone made a choice before they got behind the wheel, and now you are the one paying for it. That is the part that makes a drunk driving crash different from any other wreck. If you were hurt by an impaired driver in Sarasota, a drunk driving accident attorney in Sarasota at Legler, Murphy & Battaglia, LLP can pursue money for your medical bills, lost income, and pain while you deal with the recovery.
We have represented injured people across Southwest Florida since 1989, and we know how these cases move through the Sarasota County courts.
You should not have to argue with an insurance company on top of everything else. That is our job.
Not sure where your accident leaves you?
Call for a free case review: 941-366-3782.
Key Takeaways
- A DUI crash victim’s civil injury claim is separate from the criminal case and is the only route to financial recovery.
- Florida’s dram shop law under Florida Statute 768.125 can make a bar or vendor liable in specific situations.
- Drunk driving is one of the few categories where Florida courts allow punitive damages on top of compensatory damages.
- The filing deadline for most drunk driving injury claims is two years under Florida Statute 95.11.
- Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage can step in when the at-fault driver carried minimal or no insurance.
Do You Need a Lawyer After a Drunk Driving Crash in Sarasota?
Yes, in almost every drunk driving case you do. These crashes usually involve serious injuries, more than one source of money, and an insurance company that already knows its driver was impaired and is trying to limit what it pays.
A DUI crash is rarely a simple fender bender. Impaired driving stays one of the deadliest choices on the road, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, or NHTSA. When an impaired driver hits you, the impact tends to be harder and the injuries more severe because that driver never braked.
That combination raises the value of your claim and the reasons the insurer wants to settle it fast and cheap. Having a Sarasota drunk driver injury attorney on your side early keeps you from signing away a claim worth far more than the first offer.
Who Pays When a Drunk Driver Hurts You in Sarasota?
The impaired driver is the first source of payment, but they are often not the only one. In Florida, a bar or vendor can share responsibility in specific situations, and that matters in a city built on hospitality.
Sarasota’s nightlife runs through St. Armands Circle, downtown Main Street, and the beach bars out on Siesta Key. Most nights end fine. Some end with a driver leaving a venue impaired and getting on Tamiami Trail (US-41) or I-75. When that happens, Florida’s “dram shop” law can come into play. Dram shop is an old term for a place that sells liquor, and the law is Florida Statute 768.125. A vendor is not automatically liable just for serving an adult. It can become liable if it knowingly served alcohol to someone under 21 or to a person it knew was habitually addicted to alcohol.
Those are narrow rules, and proving them takes fast work: pulling receipts, video, and staff records before they disappear. That is one reason to call a lawyer within days, not months.
Is the Drunk Driver’s Criminal Case the Same as Your Injury Claim?
No. The criminal DUI case and your injury claim are two separate matters, and one does not pay your bills. Understanding the split is the single most important thing for a crash victim to get right.
The State of Florida brings the criminal case to punish the driver with things like fines, license suspension, or jail. You are a witness in that case, not a party, and even a guilty verdict does not put money in your pocket. Your injury claim is a separate civil case that you control, and it is where money for your losses comes from.
| Criminal DUI case | Your injury claim | |
|---|---|---|
| Who brings it | The State of Florida | You |
| Goal | Punish the driver | Pay for your losses |
| Result | Fines, license loss, jail | Money for medical bills, lost wages, pain |
| Do you get paid? | No | Yes, if the claim succeeds |
The good news is that evidence from the criminal case, such as a breath test result or the arrest report, often strengthens your civil claim.
Not sure which case affects your money? Call (941) 366-3782 and we will explain where you stand.
Can You Get Punitive Damages From a Drunk Driver in Florida?
Often, yes. Drunk driving is one of the situations where Florida law allows punitive damages, which are extra damages meant to punish reckless conduct rather than just repay your losses. Regular crashes almost never qualify. DUI crashes frequently do.
Here is why that matters to you. Most claims pay “compensatory” damages, which cover what you actually lost, like medical bills and missed paychecks. Punitive damages are added on top when a driver acted with a conscious disregard for the safety of others, and getting behind the wheel drunk is a textbook example.
A court has to approve pursuing them, and there are limits, but the possibility changes how these cases are valued and negotiated. As Sarasota car accident attorneys, we treat drunk driving as its own category for exactly this reason.
How Long Do You Have to File a Drunk Driving Injury Claim in Sarasota?
In most cases you have two years from the date of the crash to file a Florida injury lawsuit. That deadline comes from Florida Statute 95.11, which sets a two-year limit on negligence claims. Miss it and you usually lose the right to recover anything, no matter how strong your case was.
Two years sounds like a long time. It is not. Evidence fades, witnesses move, and the venue’s security footage may be recorded over in weeks. If the crash was fatal, the timeline for a Sarasota wrongful death case is also short, and the family should speak with an attorney as soon as they are able. Starting early is the difference between a claim built on solid proof and one built on memory.
Filing deadlines can change and a few narrow exceptions exist. Confirm your specific deadline with an attorney.
What If the Drunk Driver Had No Insurance, or Not Enough?
You may still be able to recover through your own policy. Many drunk driving claims end up leaning on uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage, known as UM or UIM, which is coverage you buy that pays when the at-fault driver cannot.
This surprises people. They assume the drunk driver’s insurance will cover everything, then learn the driver carried a minimum policy or none at all. If you added UM or UIM coverage to your own auto policy, it can step in. Sorting out which policies apply, and stacking them correctly, is detailed work, and it is a big part of what we do on these cases.
What If You Were Partly at Fault?
You can still recover as long as you were not mostly to blame. Florida uses a modified comparative negligence rule under Florida Statute 768.81: your recovery is reduced by your share of fault, and if you are found more than 50 percent at fault, you recover nothing.
In drunk driving cases, fault usually sits squarely on the impaired driver, but insurers still try to pin some blame on you to shrink the payout. Do not accept their version. Let a lawyer test it against the evidence first.
What a Sarasota DUI Accident Lawyer Actually Does for Your Case
We build the claim, deal with the insurers, and take it to trial if the offer is not fair. From day one we treat a drunk driving case as one that may end in front of a jury, and we prepare it that way.
In practice that means securing the venue and vehicle evidence quickly, tracking down every insurance policy that could apply, working with your doctors so the medical picture is complete, and handling the paperwork and calls so you can step back. Cases that do not settle are litigated in the 12th Judicial Circuit at the Sarasota County Courthouse on Ringling Boulevard, and we know how matters move there. For the broader picture of how these claims fit together, our Sarasota personal injury attorneys handle the full range of injury cases across the county.
You pay nothing up front. You don’t pay until and unless we win your case.
Ready to put someone on this? Call (941) 366-3782 to start your claim.
What Should You Do After a Drunk Driving Crash in Sarasota?
Get medical care first, then start protecting the claim. What you do in the first days after a DUI crash in Sarasota shapes how strong your case is months later.
A few steps carry the most weight. See a doctor even if you feel fine, because adrenaline hides injuries and a gap in treatment hands the insurer an argument. Save everything: the crash report, the name of any bar or restaurant the driver had just left, photos of the scene and your injuries, and contact information for witnesses.
Do not post about the wreck on social media, and do not accept a fast settlement offer over the phone. Then call a drunk driver injury attorney in Sarasota FL who can take over the insurance calls and lock down evidence before it disappears.
You focus on getting better. We handle the rest.
Frequently Asked Questions
No. Give them only the basic facts and do not agree to a recorded statement or a settlement. Early offers in DUI cases are almost always low because the insurer knows the claim is strong. A short call with an attorney first protects the value of your claim and costs you nothing.
Not automatic, but it helps a lot. An arrest and any test results are strong evidence of fault, and they can support a request for punitive damages. You still have to prove your injuries and losses, which is where medical records, wage documents, and a well-built claim matter.
There is no up-front cost. We work on a contingency fee, which means our fee comes out of the recovery only if we win, and the first case evaluation is free. If there is no recovery, you owe no attorney fee.
You may have a wrongful death claim, which is separate from the criminal case and belongs to the surviving family through the estate. These claims carry their own deadlines and rules. Reaching out early lets us preserve evidence before it is gone.
As soon as you are medically stable, ideally within days. Video from bars and traffic cameras, vehicle data, and witness memories all fade fast. Calling early lets us lock down proof while it still exists.
Most claims settle before trial, but not all. We prepare every drunk driving case as if a jury will decide it, and that readiness often pushes the insurer toward a fair number. If the offer stays too low, we are prepared to try the case in the 12th Judicial Circuit.
Talk to a Sarasota Drunk Driving Accident Attorney Today
An impaired driver took away your say in what happened. You get it back now. Legler, Murphy & Battaglia, PLLC has stood up for injured people in Sarasota and across Southwest Florida since 1989, and we are ready to look at your case for free.
All Injuries. All The Time.
Call 941-366-3782 for your free case review, or reach out online to get started.
